Difference between revisions of "Mail Shirts"
From The Viking Age Compendium
| Line 7: | Line 7: | ||
| colspan="7" | Article structure and content is subject to change as data is still being collected | | colspan="7" | Article structure and content is subject to change as data is still being collected | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | <br> | + | <br>{{TOClimit|3}} |
| − | [[File:Book of Maccabees1.png|150px|thumb|Short mail shirt<br>Book of Maccabees]] | + | [[File:Book of Maccabees1.png|150px|thumb|left|Short mail shirt<br>Book of Maccabees]] |
==Short mail shirts to just below the waist== | ==Short mail shirts to just below the waist== | ||
''A mail shirt that stops a couple of inches below the belt. Sleeves are usually to the elbow but can extend to the wrist.'' | ''A mail shirt that stops a couple of inches below the belt. Sleeves are usually to the elbow but can extend to the wrist.'' | ||
| Line 24: | Line 24: | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
*C1 | *C1 | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
| − | It would appear that the typical 8th - 9th century mail shirt seems to end just below the belt line. Some of them appear as though they may be vandyked or side split – see below. | + | It would appear that the typical 8th - 9th century mail shirt seems to end just below the belt line. Some of them appear as though they may be vandyked or side split – see below.<br> |
| Line 45: | Line 45: | ||
| Colspan="2" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | | Colspan="2" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
*T49 London, BL, Cotton Cleopatra C VIII f.18v, Late C10th | *T49 London, BL, Cotton Cleopatra C VIII f.18v, Late C10th | ||
| − | + | '''Literature'''<br> | |
-- | -- | ||
| − | + | '''Archaeology'''<br> | |
-- | -- | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
We have a few pictures that can be interpreted as Vandyked shirts. London, BL, Cotton Cleopatra C VIII f.18v dated to the late C10th is perhaps the most famous although it may not actually be a mail shirt. | We have a few pictures that can be interpreted as Vandyked shirts. London, BL, Cotton Cleopatra C VIII f.18v dated to the late C10th is perhaps the most famous although it may not actually be a mail shirt. | ||
[Migration era evidence?] | [Migration era evidence?] | ||
| Line 57: | Line 57: | ||
<br> | <br> | ||
| − | [[File:Codex Aureus Epternacensis f.18v 1.png|150px|thumb|Side split mail shirt<br>Codex Aureus Epternacensis f.18v]] | + | [[File:Codex Aureus Epternacensis f.18v 1.png|150px|thumb|left|Side split mail shirt<br>Codex Aureus Epternacensis f.18v]] |
==Side split mail shirt== | ==Side split mail shirt== | ||
''A side split mail shirt’s skirt is open at the sides. An unsplit mail shirt has an additional side gore added to the side of the skirt to allow movement and offer protection.'' | ''A side split mail shirt’s skirt is open at the sides. An unsplit mail shirt has an additional side gore added to the side of the skirt to allow movement and offer protection.'' | ||
| Line 71: | Line 71: | ||
| Colspan="1" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | | Colspan="1" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
* W1 National Museum, Nuremberg (Hs. 156 142) - Codex aureus Epternacensis. C.1030AD [SKODELL 2008] | * W1 National Museum, Nuremberg (Hs. 156 142) - Codex aureus Epternacensis. C.1030AD [SKODELL 2008] | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
Mail shirts are usually shown unsplit. A few of the depictions from Western European manuscripts do however show side split mail shirts. | Mail shirts are usually shown unsplit. A few of the depictions from Western European manuscripts do however show side split mail shirts. | ||
| Line 92: | Line 92: | ||
| Colspan="1" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | | Colspan="1" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
*Aachen ivory font c.1000AD (SKODELL 2008) – mid thigh | *Aachen ivory font c.1000AD (SKODELL 2008) – mid thigh | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
This seems to be the typical size of a period shirt – see illustrations above. Some drawings do show shorter mail shirts but mail shirts seem to get longer as the period progresses. | This seems to be the typical size of a period shirt – see illustrations above. Some drawings do show shorter mail shirts but mail shirts seem to get longer as the period progresses. | ||
| Line 103: | Line 103: | ||
==Long front split mail shirt to knee== | ==Long front split mail shirt to knee== | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
There appears to be 3 distinct types of front split mail shirts depicted in C11th art. A ‘Short split’, ‘Full split’ and the difficult to interpret ‘Bayeux style’. These are discussed in detail delow | There appears to be 3 distinct types of front split mail shirts depicted in C11th art. A ‘Short split’, ‘Full split’ and the difficult to interpret ‘Bayeux style’. These are discussed in detail delow | ||
| − | + | '''Literature'''<br> | |
| − | -- | + | --<br> |
| − | + | '''Archaeology'''<br> | |
| − | -- | + | --<br> |
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
They appear common on such sources as the Bayeux Tapestry and continue to make appearances on numerous manuscripts from the 1060’s onwards although they nether totally replace the traditional unsplit mail shirt. | They appear common on such sources as the Bayeux Tapestry and continue to make appearances on numerous manuscripts from the 1060’s onwards although they nether totally replace the traditional unsplit mail shirt. | ||
| − | [[File:Hildesheimer Cathedral.png|150px|thumb|Mail shirt with short front split<br>Hildesheimer Cathedral]] | + | [[File:Hildesheimer Cathedral.png|150px|thumb|left|Mail shirt with short front split<br>Hildesheimer Cathedral]] |
===Short Split=== | ===Short Split=== | ||
''A mail shirt to the knee with a small slit in the skirt and sleeves to the elbow.'' | ''A mail shirt to the knee with a small slit in the skirt and sleeves to the elbow.'' | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
* T44 Boulogne, MS11 f.104v late C10th (Possible – detail hidden) | * T44 Boulogne, MS11 f.104v late C10th (Possible – detail hidden) | ||
* A carving at Hildesheimer cathedral [SKODELL 2008] | * A carving at Hildesheimer cathedral [SKODELL 2008] | ||
| Line 124: | Line 124: | ||
===Bayeux Style=== | ===Bayeux Style=== | ||
''Interpreted as either a front split mail shirt or alternatively a mail shirt with mail shorts.'' | ''Interpreted as either a front split mail shirt or alternatively a mail shirt with mail shorts.'' | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
* Bayeux Tapestry c.1076AD [WILSON 1985] | * Bayeux Tapestry c.1076AD [WILSON 1985] | ||
* T86 The Old English Hexatech 1025-1050AD | * T86 The Old English Hexatech 1025-1050AD | ||
* Winchester carving 1050-1100AD [WILSON 1985] | * Winchester carving 1050-1100AD [WILSON 1985] | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
The ‘mail shorts’ theory has been dismissed by Wilson [WILSON 1985], Grape [GRAPE 1994] and others. | The ‘mail shorts’ theory has been dismissed by Wilson [WILSON 1985], Grape [GRAPE 1994] and others. | ||
===Full Split=== | ===Full Split=== | ||
| − | + | '''Art'''<br> | |
* Bayeux Tapestry c.1076AD [WILSON 1985] | * Bayeux Tapestry c.1076AD [WILSON 1985] | ||
* R1 Dijon, Bibliotheque Municipale MS 14 fol.13, Bible of St. Etienne, 1109-1111AD – Picture of Goliath [SKODELL 2008] | * R1 Dijon, Bibliotheque Municipale MS 14 fol.13, Bible of St. Etienne, 1109-1111AD – Picture of Goliath [SKODELL 2008] | ||
== Mail shirt ring sizes== | == Mail shirt ring sizes== | ||
| − | + | '''Literature'''<br> | |
| − | -- | + | --<br> |
===6 - 8mm alternating riveted & welded=== | ===6 - 8mm alternating riveted & welded=== | ||
| Line 153: | Line 153: | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Archaeology'''<br> | |
*Gjermundbu, Norway, 980AD (TWEDDLE 1992) riveted & welded, internal ring size = approx. 5.5 - 7.3 mm. | *Gjermundbu, Norway, 980AD (TWEDDLE 1992) riveted & welded, internal ring size = approx. 5.5 - 7.3 mm. | ||
*Gotland, Sweden, (TWEDDLE 1992) graves 14.7 & 14.8. Riveted & welded, internal ring size = approx. 7.4 – 7.6mm. Interestingly some copper alloy rings were in the Gotland finds. | *Gotland, Sweden, (TWEDDLE 1992) graves 14.7 & 14.8. Riveted & welded, internal ring size = approx. 7.4 – 7.6mm. Interestingly some copper alloy rings were in the Gotland finds. | ||
*Sutton Hoo c.650AD (POLLINGTON 2006, p.152) - 8mm links, alternate riveted and butt-jointed, to mid thigh | *Sutton Hoo c.650AD (POLLINGTON 2006, p.152) - 8mm links, alternate riveted and butt-jointed, to mid thigh | ||
*Dublin (HALPIN 2008, p.179) | *Dublin (HALPIN 2008, p.179) | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
Most of the Viking Age finds seem to be in this size range. | Most of the Viking Age finds seem to be in this size range. | ||
| Line 173: | Line 173: | ||
| Colspan="4" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Optional]] | | Colspan="4" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Optional]] | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Archaeology'''<br> | |
-- | -- | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
Although we have no finds of 100% riveted shirts from 800-????, it was felt that they are better than ‘butted mail’ and are thus included under optional. | Although we have no finds of 100% riveted shirts from 800-????, it was felt that they are better than ‘butted mail’ and are thus included under optional. | ||
| Line 190: | Line 190: | ||
| Colspan="4" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | | Colspan="4" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Archaeology'''<br> | |
*Tuna, Gotland (TWEDDLE 1992) has an internal link diameter up to approx.10mm in size | *Tuna, Gotland (TWEDDLE 1992) has an internal link diameter up to approx.10mm in size | ||
*Russia (D’AMATO 2012, p.34) some links measuring up to 25mm | *Russia (D’AMATO 2012, p.34) some links measuring up to 25mm | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
It appears that Eastern mail shirts could have even larger rings with some from Russia measuring up to 25mm. (D’AMATO 2012, p.34) | It appears that Eastern mail shirts could have even larger rings with some from Russia measuring up to 25mm. (D’AMATO 2012, p.34) | ||
| Line 211: | Line 211: | ||
| Colspan="4" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | | Colspan="4" style="text-align: center;"| [[Recreation guide|Allowable]] | ||
|} | |} | ||
| − | + | '''Archaeology'''<br> | |
*York, England, C8th (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1003) Coppergate helmet,4 links. | *York, England, C8th (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1003) Coppergate helmet,4 links. | ||
*Gotland, Sweden, C9th-12th (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1185) Graves 14.7 & 8. This had two rows of copper alloy links at a possible vertical edge. | *Gotland, Sweden, C9th-12th (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1185) Graves 14.7 & 8. This had two rows of copper alloy links at a possible vertical edge. | ||
| − | + | '''Discussion'''<br> | |
The Coppergate helmet possibly had either a double row of copper alloy links edging the aventail or alternatively they could have been talismans. Copper alloy talismans and edges are frequently found on medieval mail shirts (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1003). | The Coppergate helmet possibly had either a double row of copper alloy links edging the aventail or alternatively they could have been talismans. Copper alloy talismans and edges are frequently found on medieval mail shirts (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1003). | ||
| Line 234: | Line 234: | ||
==See Also== | ==See Also== | ||
| − | + | ==References== | |
* [*GRAPE 1994] GRAPE, Wolfgang. The Bayeux Tapestry. 1994 | * [*GRAPE 1994] GRAPE, Wolfgang. The Bayeux Tapestry. 1994 | ||
* [*NICOLLE 2005] NICOLLE, David. Carolingian Cavalryman AD 768-987 (Osprey Warrior 96). 2005 | * [*NICOLLE 2005] NICOLLE, David. Carolingian Cavalryman AD 768-987 (Osprey Warrior 96). 2005 | ||
Revision as of 21:18, 14 August 2012
 |
This article's completion rating is 2 out of 5 | |||||
| Article structure and content is subject to change as data is still being collected | ||||||
Contents
- 1 Short mail shirts to just below the waist
- 2 Vandyked mail shirt
- 3 Side split mail shirt
- 4 Long unsplit mail shirts from below groin to knee
- 5 Long front split mail shirt to knee
- 6 Mail shirt ring sizes
- 7 Copper alloy mail links used for decoration
- 8 Mail edged with leather
- 9 See Also
- 10 References
Short mail shirts to just below the waist
A mail shirt that stops a couple of inches below the belt. Sleeves are usually to the elbow but can extend to the wrist.
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Optional | Allowable | ||
Art
- C1
Discussion
It would appear that the typical 8th - 9th century mail shirt seems to end just below the belt line. Some of them appear as though they may be vandyked or side split – see below.
Vandyked mail shirt
Vandykes are a triangular finish to the hem and sometimes the cuff of a mail shirt.
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Allowable | Allowable | ||
Art
- T49 London, BL, Cotton Cleopatra C VIII f.18v, Late C10th
Literature
--
Archaeology
--
Discussion
We have a few pictures that can be interpreted as Vandyked shirts. London, BL, Cotton Cleopatra C VIII f.18v dated to the late C10th is perhaps the most famous although it may not actually be a mail shirt.
[Migration era evidence?]
Side split mail shirt
A side split mail shirt’s skirt is open at the sides. An unsplit mail shirt has an additional side gore added to the side of the skirt to allow movement and offer protection.
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Optional | Allowable | ||
Art
- W1 National Museum, Nuremberg (Hs. 156 142) - Codex aureus Epternacensis. C.1030AD [SKODELL 2008]
Discussion
Mail shirts are usually shown unsplit. A few of the depictions from Western European manuscripts do however show side split mail shirts.
Long unsplit mail shirts from below groin to knee
A mail shirt that reaches to the thigh, with sleeves that usually come to the elbow.
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Optional | Allowable | Allowable | |
Art
- Aachen ivory font c.1000AD (SKODELL 2008) – mid thigh
Discussion
This seems to be the typical size of a period shirt – see illustrations above. Some drawings do show shorter mail shirts but mail shirts seem to get longer as the period progresses.
Long front split mail shirt to knee
Art
There appears to be 3 distinct types of front split mail shirts depicted in C11th art. A ‘Short split’, ‘Full split’ and the difficult to interpret ‘Bayeux style’. These are discussed in detail delow
Literature
--
Archaeology
--
Discussion
They appear common on such sources as the Bayeux Tapestry and continue to make appearances on numerous manuscripts from the 1060’s onwards although they nether totally replace the traditional unsplit mail shirt.
Short Split
A mail shirt to the knee with a small slit in the skirt and sleeves to the elbow.
Art
- T44 Boulogne, MS11 f.104v late C10th (Possible – detail hidden)
- A carving at Hildesheimer cathedral [SKODELL 2008]
- 980AD Byzantine [NICOLLE 2005]:p.51
Bayeux Style
Interpreted as either a front split mail shirt or alternatively a mail shirt with mail shorts.
Art
- Bayeux Tapestry c.1076AD [WILSON 1985]
- T86 The Old English Hexatech 1025-1050AD
- Winchester carving 1050-1100AD [WILSON 1985]
Discussion
The ‘mail shorts’ theory has been dismissed by Wilson [WILSON 1985], Grape [GRAPE 1994] and others.
Full Split
Art
- Bayeux Tapestry c.1076AD [WILSON 1985]
- R1 Dijon, Bibliotheque Municipale MS 14 fol.13, Bible of St. Etienne, 1109-1111AD – Picture of Goliath [SKODELL 2008]
Mail shirt ring sizes
Literature
--
6 - 8mm alternating riveted & welded
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Allowable | |||
Archaeology
- Gjermundbu, Norway, 980AD (TWEDDLE 1992) riveted & welded, internal ring size = approx. 5.5 - 7.3 mm.
- Gotland, Sweden, (TWEDDLE 1992) graves 14.7 & 14.8. Riveted & welded, internal ring size = approx. 7.4 – 7.6mm. Interestingly some copper alloy rings were in the Gotland finds.
- Sutton Hoo c.650AD (POLLINGTON 2006, p.152) - 8mm links, alternate riveted and butt-jointed, to mid thigh
- Dublin (HALPIN 2008, p.179)
Discussion
Most of the Viking Age finds seem to be in this size range.
6 - 8mm riveted
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Optional | |||
Archaeology
--
Discussion
Although we have no finds of 100% riveted shirts from 800-????, it was felt that they are better than ‘butted mail’ and are thus included under optional.
Riveted links over 8mm
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Allowable | |||
Archaeology
- Tuna, Gotland (TWEDDLE 1992) has an internal link diameter up to approx.10mm in size
- Russia (D’AMATO 2012, p.34) some links measuring up to 25mm
Discussion
It appears that Eastern mail shirts could have even larger rings with some from Russia measuring up to 25mm. (D’AMATO 2012, p.34)
Butted links
--
Copper alloy mail links used for decoration
A double row of copper alloy links used to edge mail shirts and aventails.
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Allowable | |||
Archaeology
- York, England, C8th (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1003) Coppergate helmet,4 links.
- Gotland, Sweden, C9th-12th (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1185) Graves 14.7 & 8. This had two rows of copper alloy links at a possible vertical edge.
Discussion
The Coppergate helmet possibly had either a double row of copper alloy links edging the aventail or alternatively they could have been talismans. Copper alloy talismans and edges are frequently found on medieval mail shirts (TWEDDLE 1992, p.1003).
Mail edged with leather
A strip of leather sown over the edge of the mail shirt
| 800-899 | 900-979 | 980-1040 | 1041-1100 |
| Allowable | |||
See Also
References
- [GRAPE 1994] ^ GRAPE, Wolfgang. The Bayeux Tapestry. 1994
- [NICOLLE 2005] ^ NICOLLE, David. Carolingian Cavalryman AD 768-987 (Osprey Warrior 96). 2005
- [SKODELL 2008] ^ 1 2 3 SKODELL, Henry. “Schutzausrüstung zur zeit der Schlacht von Hastings (Protective Equipment Present at the Battle of Hastings).” Website 2008.
- [WILSON 1985] ^ 1 2 3 4 WILSON, David M. The Bayeux Tapestry. 1985
